An extrajudicial murder in a Karachi park

Television reports showing a young man shot in cold blood by the Rangers in Karachi are disturbing to watch (I feel physically sick after watching it). An unidentified cameraman filmed the episode and made the footage available to TV channels – it’s online if anyone has the heart to watch it but better to read this report about the incident by AFP reporter Hasan Mansoor: Five soldiers arrested after Pakistan park killing.

The extra-judicial murder of this young man, Sarfaraz Shah, at the long, coastal Benazir Bhutto Park opposite Boat Basin (a hub of food shops and cafes) in Karachi, is a reminder of the impunity that our security forces enjoy. They claimed he had tried to rob a policeman’s family. Even if he had succeed, they had no business shooting at him. What happened to due process of law? Why aren’t the Rangers and other security people given basic human rights and legal training?

Extrajudicial killing in Pakistan is not new. But this is first time TV channels showed footage of it, sparking off public outrage. Reminds me of the public outrage at the Swat flogging after that video went on air; the taliban and their ilk committed many other atrocities that we never actually saw. Videos of what looks like the Pakistani soldiers lining up and killing young boys have done the rounds on the internet, but the channels didn’t broadcast those as they were ‘un-verified’.

Now, coupled with the increasing calls for the accountability of the security apparatus, perhaps there’ll be some changes. The HRCP filed a petition in 2007, asking the court to ask the intelligence agencies and the defence ministry about laws or rules that authorise their functioning and what their mandate is, and for the interior and defence ministries to spell out who the intelligence agencies are accountable to (see this excellent interview of Asma Jahangir in the Herald).

Noman Quadri, an activist in Karachi, suggests erecting a small monument with a “peace dove with red blood spots on it at the place the poor guy was murdered at point blank in the Benazir Bhutto Park. The park named for the victim of extremism has now its own victim waiting for justice.”

The suo moto against the release of Atiqa Odho for a minor transgression shows the misplaced priorities of Pakistan's courts

But the Chief Justice obviously has more important things to do, like taking suo moto notice after the authorities released the public relations face of Musharraf’s party, well known actress Atiqa Odho, who had been caught with two bottles of wine coming into Islamabad airport (she has quit Musharraf’s partydue to the embarrassment caused by the row). He has yet to accept the Request for Suo Moto action against vigilantism, incitement to violence delivered to him on February 10, 2011, signed by hundreds of prominent citizens.

5 Responses

  1. Would some one please care to tell me who made this video of the boy being killed? And why he didn’t do anything about it? And why the rangers allowed the the footage to be made in the first place? No I do not understand and I will NOT watch it either.( I dont have the heart to watch it)


    • See the new post about who made it. I have some questions too, similar to the ones you’ve just asked. And yes, please don’t watch it. 😦


  2. […] An extrajudicial murder in a Karachi park […]


  3. Pakistani Security forces ( especially our police ) has been made to harrass and kill innocent people of Pakistan. They don’t even dare to capture or kill a criminal. Almost half of the criminals ( Docoits, rapist, Abductors, thieves etc) or from Pakistan Police. There should be strict action against the police officers who are involved in such henious crimes. They are mother fucking and they offer their daughters and mothers to their seniors at nights to get their promotions.

    Shame on Pakistani Security Forces.


  4. The real casualty in this case is the truth. It is a rotten society wherein every thing is upside down. When the society loses any sense of justice and becomes at war with itself every thing becomes fair. Here you are either on criminals side or on rangers’ side depending on your experience with either of them. Seeking justice from our legal system against a dacoit is itself is risky and torturous. So the best way to deal with a dacoit is to kill him or be killed or better still to burn him as this is an open war now and all is fair in love and war, they say.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: