Remembering Hal Gould, a friend of South Asia


I wrote this piece recently about someone I was honoured to consider a friend although we never met. Hal Gould came to mind when we launched Sapan, the South Asia Peace Action Network, earlier this year. I knew he was over 90 by then, a few years older than my late father Dr M. Sarwar, who Hal had felt an affinity with. We’re in a pandemic and I hadn’t heard from him in a while.

Hal and I had been in touch since early 2008 after he read my op-ed in Dawn, An inconvenient truth” (Feb. 22, 2008) about Pakistan’s ‘return to democracy’, marking the country’s first-ever peaceful electoral transfer of power. He had quoted from it in his column for the then newly launched online magazine South Asia Monitor, in which he urged America and the world to allow democracy to take root in Pakistan without outside interference.

My piece had emerged in response to an American friend’s outraged comment: “What kind of democracy is it that puts the fate of the country in the hands of a Nawaz Sharif and an Asif Zardari?” Trying to put the issue in context, I had written: “It’s surely not worse than a democracy which puts the fate of America – and the world – in the hands of a George W. Bush… TWICE!” I added that India had twice elected a right-wing BJP government-backed by religious militants. This was, of course, before Trump and Modi.

Interesting times, these. As a scholar who has done seminal work on caste in India, I am sure Hal would have had something to say about the Dismantling Hindutva conference taking place this weekend that is under massive attack from those who refuse to distinguish between Hindus and Hindutva…

Then came the sad update about his stroke, followed by news of his passing – shared by his son to the Friends of Hal email list that Hal used to post to. I found it hard to put the piece together in the middle of all that was going on but I felt Hal deserved a proper remembrance.

Hal’s son Armeen eventually sent around an obituary which I’ve drawn from, including a list of the books Hal authored. For the photos I’m indebted to historian Richard Barnett – who I had interviewed years ago for The Frontier Post – who connected me with another friend of Hal and of South Asia, Philip McEldowney at University of Virginia who dug about and sent some.

Obituary on Hal Gould in South Asia Monitor, cross-posted to our recently launched Sapan website. Rest in peace Hal. We will keep learning from you.

Here’s the full piece:

When some of us launched a South Asia initiative earlier this year, Hal Gould came to mind. I wondered how he was. We were in a pandemic, and I knew he was over 90. I hadn’t heard from him in a while.

Hal and I had been in touch since early 2008 when he emailed me after coming across my oped in Dawn “An inconvenient truth” (Feb. 22, 2008) about Pakistan’s ‘return to democracy’, the marking the country’s first ever peaceful electoral transfer of power.

I had written it in response to an American friend’s outraged comment: “What kind of democracy is it that puts the fate of the country in the hands of a Nawaz Sharif and an Asif Zardari?” Trying to put the issue in context, I had written: “It’s surely not worse than a democracy which puts the fate of America – and the world –in the hands of a George W. Bush… TWICE!”

I added that India had twice elected a right-wing BJP government backed by religious militants. This was, of course, before Trump and Modi.

Hal had quoted my piece in his fortnightly column in the then new online magazine South Asia Monitor. He wanted me to see it “right away” before it was published. His piece urged America and the world to allow democracy to take root in Pakistan without outside interference.

I replied appreciating his piece and correcting a couple of misconceptions. He replied immediately, quick to accept the difference in opinion, and ended with a warm: “Call me Hal, everyone does”.

He was then 82, a Visiting Scholar at the Center for South Asian Studies at the University of Virginia, with three volumes on U.P. that are considered seminal work. His specialisations included political anthropology, South Asian civilization, and particularly India’s caste system.

I was honoured to be added to his email list of nearly 80 friends and South Asia scholars that he regularly copied (not blind-copied) his writings to – Friends of Hal, or FOH for short. He in turn joined my beena-issues yahoogroup where I curated news and information and shared my pieces.

Beyond the mass emails and newsletters, we developed a personal correspondence, bonding over shared values and common friends and acquaintances. His wife Ketayun, a Parsi, was also a PhD.

He shared his delight about the rave reviews of his recently published book in India, “Sikhs, Swamis, Students and Spies: The Rise of the India Lobby in the United States, 1900 to 1946” (Sage, 2006) – even then prime minister Manmohan Singh “said it was his favorite read of 2007!” The book got its title from a phrase Hal found in a 1911 Modern Review article by Lala Har Dayal, a central figure in the formation of the Ghadr Party. Dayal had written that there are four types of Indians in the USA: “Sikhs, swamis, students and spies…”

I learnt that he had many interests, a passionate commitment to democracy and freedom of expression, and was a consummate humanist unafraid to take on controversial subjects. In December 2013, he wrote a piece titled “Is homosexuality really unnatural?”

To see heterosexuality as a hereditary norm and homosexuality as abnormal and pathological “was/is based upon pre-scientific, culturally normatized ignorance of sexual biology… a failure to understand the flexibility of sexual biology and the crucial social function heterosexuality performs.”

“Now there’s no longer any need to brainwash everybody on the morality of reproductive behavior because we now know that it ain’t necessary,” he wrote in an email later. “But after millions of years of otherwise, it’ll take a while for human societies to get over it.”

Despite feeling technologically challenged, he took the plunge and started a blog. Hal Gould’s Corner (http://haroldgouldscorner.com/ which has sadly lapsed) aimed to “advance our knowledge and promote discussion of issues pertaining to South, Southwest, Southeast and East Asia with special emphasis on India, Pakistan, Bangladesh and Afghanistan.” He continued to post his pieces to the FOH list.

His last Hal Gould’s Corner post was a lyrical literary tribute to President Barack Obama, in February 2017. His last oped for South Asia Monitor, Rise of Populist Demagogue: US Paying Price of Flawed Electoral System, was published in February 2017

Hal was four years older than my father Dr M. Sarwar, a medical doctor who had led Pakistan’s first nationwide student movement, Democratic Students Federation, DSF. After my father passed away in May 2009, I shared information about the student movement to my email list and created a blog, www.drsarwar.wordpress.com.  Hal read the material with “great interest and empathy”.

“The more I read the more I regret that I never had a chance to meet him and get to know him,” he wrote about my father. “Our political careers were running parallel back in the ’50s; had we met we would have had much to talk about and share. It is clear that he was a consummate secular and democratic man, an exemplification of what Pakistan desperately needed, and still needs, instead of the military-mullah nexus that has delivered Pakistan to its present dreary state”.

Hal’s last email to FOH was sad and brief paying tribute to President Barack Obama, in February 2017. He built upon it for what was perhaps his last oped for South Asia Monitor headlined Rise Of Populist Demagogue: US Paying Price Of Flawed Electoral System, published in February 2017.  

Hal suffered a stroke at the end of May this year. Less than two months later, on July 2, 2021, he passed away peacefully at his home in Delray Beach, Florida, aged 95.

In early 2017 Hal gave up his office chair due to failing eyesight, writes his son Armeen in an obituary emailed to FOH later. He also shared his father’s last holiday greeting in December 2016. It provides a neat synopsis of Hal’s life, marked with his hallmark wry humour and courage:

I am now 90 years old and will be 91 in February and so my life has slowed to a walk (with a cane!). So like all fading beauties like me my life is mostly a congeries of memories and reminiscences of all the good and bad my life and career have been heir to. And I have to believe that the good has, by and large, outweighed the bad.  How many persons after all commenced life in a small Rhode Island Swamp Yankee town and escaped the throes of the Great  Depression, fought in World War II, finagled an education for himself under the GI Bill, spent half his adult life in India, married a Persian queen, published nine books, rooted for the Boston Red Sox and the Pittsburgh Steelers (and still does!),  professored in three great universities (Pittsburgh, Illinois, Virginia), circumnavigated the globe six times, and enjoyed so many precious and wonderful friendships in the process?

It’s been a delightful journal through life and time. And what a pity that it’s nearly over! 

Hal had survived a serious automobile accident in August 2009 in which the vehicle was demolished. He had been in the passenger seat wearing a seat bel but the air bag didn’t deploy. A broken neck and other injuries kept him from his work until the following summer. “To be very frank, this is a hell of a setback!” he wrote understatedly.

In our last correspondence, April 2014, apologising for a delay in replying to my email, he explained that his wife had contracted Parkinson’s disease and he spent much of his time caring for her. “My Karma has gone a bit awry. Not to mention the fact that I am just plain growing old. I believe your father had to face that, did he not”. 

That is true, I replied, adding that my father had once said in Urdu: “It’s ok. The car gets old, the parts get worn out”.

Forgetting that Hal spoke the language, I hadn’t occurred to me to include the original words. He wrote back asking for the remark in Roman Urdu. Unfortunately, I missed seeing the email.

I think Hal would appreciate and enjoy the Roman Urdu rendition of what my father had said: “GaRi purani ho jaati hai, purzey ghiss jaatey haiN”.

It is good to know that his son is creating an archive of Hal’s articles from the past 20 years, and that South Asia Monitor is also re-archiving the material lost due to a server change. Hal’s work also lives on through his books, that hopefully will continue to be used at universities as part of the Asian Studies curriculum.

Dear Hal, thank you for your scholarship and vision, humanism, humour and courage, for Friends of Hal, and for connecting me to South Asia Monitor. Rest in peace.

BOX:

Books authored by Harold A. Gould

  • The Hindu Caste System, Vol. 1: Sacralization of a Social Order (Delhi: Chanakya Publications, 1987)
  • The Hindu Caste System, Vol 2: Caste Adaptation in Modernizing Indian Society (Delhi: Chanakya Publications, 1988). 
  • The Hindu Caste System, Vol. 3: Politics and Caste (Delhi: Chanakya Publications, 1990). 
  • India Votes: Alliance Politics and Minority Government in the Ninth and Tenth General Elections (co-edited with Sumit Ganguly, Westview Press, 1993).
  • The Hope and the Reality: US-Indian Relations from Roosevelt to Reagan (co-edited with Sumit Ganguly, Westview Press, 1992).
  • Grass Roots Politics in India: Century of Political Evolution in Faizabad District (Oxford & IBH, 1995)
  • India and the United States in a Changing World (co-edited with Ashok Kapur, Y. K. Malik, and Arthur G. Rubinoff, SAGE, 2002
  • Sikhs, Swamis, Students, and Spies: The India Lobby in the United States, 1900-1946 (SAGE, 2006
  • The South Asia Story: The first sixty years of US relations with India and Pakistan (SAGE, 2010).

(ends)


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: